Monday, 1 July 2013
Canada is dead. Long live Canada
Canada has a few ghosts. Not individual spooks - collective hauntings.
Nations are imagined. We think them in order for them to be true. Benedict Anderson told us this and it's so true it's now almost a cliché to say it.
But what happens when we dream a different dream? Minds do flicker from one thing to the next. Even if the collective idea of a nation has a little more ballast, it too sways and moves, finds other moorings. We reimagine the nation.
I was thinking of this as I read Robert Fulford's acerbic look back on the era of intense Canadian nationalism in the 1960s and 1970s. Fulford particularly recalled the great George Grant and his Lament for a Nation and Donald Creighton and his grumpy anti-Americanism.
For Fulford, the silly illogic of these men is clear in retrospect. Wasn't Canada supposed to disappear, a victim of American imperialism, Liberal party perfidy and British ineptness? And yet here we still are, another Canada Day come and gone. The nation stands. Folks gather on Parliament Hill and listen to the latest pop star, endure the platitudes of the latest prime minister. In Quebec, the renters move from apartment to apartment, and in small towns like the one I live in, they wear red and white clothes, gather their kids around to look at fire trucks and tractors, and then eat some cake. Happy birthday Canada. You're still here. Where's the beer?
Only Fulford couldn't be more wrong. The Canada of Creighton and Grant is long dead. You can still sometimes see the ghostly entrails in a cranky letter to the editor, in the dreams of Tory staffers on parliament hill, and wherever you see someone flying a Red Ensign. A ghostly presence at best.
This is the Canada that celebrated Dominion Day, that admired Canada's place in the British Empire and Commonwealth of Nations, not as a kind of subservient underling (always the insult from anyone in Quebec and, as the years went by, more and more 'with-it' English Canadians) but as a nation with a British history and British traditions.
Canada is around still, but not this Canada. You'll sometimes hear hints of this, and more than that, in Harper's speeches. But even as he speaks the words, his policies are simply those of Liberal governments before him: more continentalism, more American-style liberalism, less and less of the Red Tory touch.
We don't necessarily have to bemoan this. Many might happily celebrate it. But Fulford is entirely wrong to think that just because this country with the same name still exists that it is indeed still the same country.
Canada is dead. Long live Canada.
Friday, 28 June 2013
What's in an Ngram
I'm late to a couple of games here - first the great Dusty Bookcase blog of Brian Busby, and then (via his great post on the change from L M Montgomery to Lucy Maud Montgomery) to the fascinating, time-wasting, and somewhat useful joys of Google's Ngram Viewer.
This is the tool that graphs the appearance of terms in google's library of ebooks. Admittedly, this isn't a perfect database, but what emerges from it can still be very intriguing.
I started with something that had been on my mind, the novelist Ralph Connor. I'm waiting for an article I've written on Connor to appear in the May 2013 issue of Histoire Sociale/ Social History. So I plucked in the name of Ralph Connor and compared it to L. M. Montgomery. I had written in the article that Connor was by far the better known novelist in the early years of the century. Here's what emerged:
I thought that perhaps I was missing something so I also then included Lucy Maud Montgomery:
It's always nice to have something that you already think to be the case confirmed (confirmation bias and all). I knew from other documents that Connor had been Canada's leading author in the early years of the twentieth century, and certainly that he had been widely popular outside of Canada as well, especially in the United States. But I thought I'd do one more comparison so I compared Connor with Anne of Green Gables, thinking that this one term might have often stood in for Montgomery herself.
This is the tool that graphs the appearance of terms in google's library of ebooks. Admittedly, this isn't a perfect database, but what emerges from it can still be very intriguing.
I started with something that had been on my mind, the novelist Ralph Connor. I'm waiting for an article I've written on Connor to appear in the May 2013 issue of Histoire Sociale/ Social History. So I plucked in the name of Ralph Connor and compared it to L. M. Montgomery. I had written in the article that Connor was by far the better known novelist in the early years of the century. Here's what emerged:
I thought that perhaps I was missing something so I also then included Lucy Maud Montgomery:
It's always nice to have something that you already think to be the case confirmed (confirmation bias and all). I knew from other documents that Connor had been Canada's leading author in the early years of the twentieth century, and certainly that he had been widely popular outside of Canada as well, especially in the United States. But I thought I'd do one more comparison so I compared Connor with Anne of Green Gables, thinking that this one term might have often stood in for Montgomery herself.
This probably gives the best representation, showing Connor as the more popular novelist in the early 20th century, but not by as much. And the real change came, as I suspected, in the midst of the rise of CanLit in the 70s and especially with the Anne of Green Gables films and then the Avonlea TV series in the 90s.
Finally, I thought I'd test out the book I'm currently writing, on the afterlife of Mackenzie King. Here is how he fares:
And here again I was pleasantly surprised to see that the mention of King soars after he dies - that it is in this context that he enters the great meaning-making machine of public memory. I was a bit surprised to see the most mentions came in the late 50s, early 60s as I thought the peak might have come in the 1970s. But I wasn't at all surprised to see that mentions start to fade away in the 1990s to today. So this argument I'm developing about the way Mackenzie King mattered to a couple of generations of Canadians in the years after he died, might not be that far wrong after all. Thank you google Ngram.
Thursday, 27 June 2013
A fair biography of whom???!
If you worked in a bookstore, what would you say to someone who asked you for a 'fair' biography of Hitler? Would you throw them out the door? would you be unable to speak, your jaw on the floor? or would you show them what was in stock?
It's a question addressed in a wonderful blog post over at stevereads - and my guess is it should have many academics squirming.
This is all à propos of a review in the latest TLS on Pope Piux III. You know, Hitler's favourite Pope.
Tuesday, 25 June 2013
Where Wars Happen
Reading through C P
Champion's latest essay in The Dorchester Review on '1812 & theFathers of Confederation' I could have been thinking several things:
- that
Champion loves to wield historical evidence with a burning poker, thrusting it
into the eyes of left historians - reminding folks that the war of 1812 used to
be part of a left history narrative of defiance of American dominance, à la
James Laxer; simply repeating the inane line by Ian McKay in a letter to Canada's
History Magazine that contemporary 'Ottawa, its streets bedecked with
War of 1812 banners, has the martial air of ... 1930s Berlin'; or castigating a
host of Canadian history bloggers on the way they have hysterically attacked
the Harper government's war of 1812 commemoration schemes.
- that, for all of its vitriol,
Champion’s essay nevertheless remains interesting and makes some solid and
sober assessments of its topic. After quoting Heritage Minister James Moore
making a rather abrupt and too strong assertion of the link between 1812 and
Confederation Champion goes on to write that while not all would agree with
Moore,:
‘Still, many of the delegates at Charlottetown and Quebec in 1864 did have family, friends, or neighbours who were participants in the War or victims of American pillage. Their family experiences comprise at least part of the Canadian and Maritime establishments’ collective memory of 1812 and its antecedents, the Revolutionary War and the flight of the Loyalists. Some of the delegates were descendants of officers deprived of their property and livelihood in the American War. But even those immigrant delegates such as Macdonald, George Brown and others who settled in Canada after 1814 had also been exposed to memories of the War of 1812 in their youth, at school, in church, in the periodicals they read, and on the political hustings.’
The rest of the essay then is a detailed, biographical level
uncovering of these personal stories, the way chance and circumstance combined
to connect anyone with anything.
But mostly what I was thinking was this:
- that the places where
historians debate these issues is changing. We still write books and publish
scholarly articles that take months and years to emerge. But when it comes to
actually talking about our profession in an on-going fashion, in almost
real-time (and sometimes in what seems like super-fast-time) it is on blogs, on
twitter and the links one gets in these venues to newspaper op-ed pieces,
literary review website and the like.
- I know this is a bit like a
fish saying that water exists. But oddly it seems that this might still need to
be said. Champion takes on a number of scholars who have staked out positions,
but it’s notable how many are bloggers, and how many comments he quotes come
online.
- For those scholars already blogging or on
twitter or commenting on these kinds of sites, this is all too obvious. My
sense, though, is that this is still a minority in the profession. Am I wrong?
Image Source: Dorchester Review
Monday, 17 June 2013
From the Archives
A story from the Montreal Gazette on 9 December 1954 gives a glimpse of a different era in our national archives. The material comes in a column by Arthur Blakely who wrote on political happenings in Ottawa. The column opens up proudly noting how many new collections of private political papers that the archives is collecting, including the papers of every Canadian prime minister since 1867 with the exception of Bennett (papers at UNB). Most are open for research, though some like the then recently deceased cabinet minister Ian Mackenzie were to be closed for some time (in that case until 1975).
So that in itself is a story - a time when journalists were trumpeting the many new collections of private papers that LAC gathered into the national fold.
And then of course there is the now quaint idea that historians were to be treated with some respect: that is, Blakely notes that many papers are closed but 'they are available to serious historians but not to scandal seekers.'
I wouldn't exactly go along with the distinction all of the time. But one does hearken back to a time when LAC acknowledged and appreciated the special relationship between the national archives and the scholars of the nation's history. Elitist? Absolutely. But also a bit more honest than today.
Image: LAC website.
Tuesday, 11 June 2013
History Quiz Anyone?
History Today has put out there new history quiz today. They billed it as 'the web's toughest history quiz'. I didn't think so at first but it gets harder.
Give it a try here.
Disclosure: for some amazing reason, I scored 10/12 even though I was guessing as the quiz went on... Fun though.
Thursday, 6 June 2013
On being plagiarized...
Plagiarism is a triangular and not just two-way relationship. I confess to mostly thinking about plagiarism (when I'm obliged to think of it - which is of course every time I mark) as being just between the student and me. Not so.
Over at the LRB blog, Charles Hartmann describes what it felt like to be the plagiarizee. The poet thief changed the title and butchered the metre, but he says that the worst was that, as he put it, 'the plagiarist assumed my poem was too obscure for anyone to discover his theft'.
My closest brush with being 'stolen' was finding an online essay for sale that was based on an article I wrote. In absolutely brutal prose, someone was selling an essay that students could submit in any class that might have assigned my article and, for some odd reason, based an assignment around it. At the time, I was actually a bit chuffed. A compliment of sorts. But I did want to correct the grammar.
Any historians with plagiarizee experiences to share?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



